Auction or Private Sale? What Southeast Nebraska Farmers Should Know Before Selling Equipment

If you have equipment to sell, you have two main choices: sell it yourself or sell it at auction. Both can work. The right one depends on what you are selling, how fast you need it gone, and how much of the work you want to take on.
When a private sale makes sense
A private sale can work well when you are selling one or two pieces, you already have a buyer in mind, and you have time to wait. You set the price, you talk to every caller, and you handle the showings, the paperwork, and the payment.
The trade-off is time and risk. You field the calls and texts, meet buyers who may not show up, and decide whether a check is good. If your price is too high, the machine sits. If it is too low, you never know how much money you left behind.
When an auction makes sense
An auction works best when you want a firm sale date, you have several pieces to sell, or you want the market to set the price. Competitive bidding lets buyers decide what the equipment is worth on sale day, instead of you guessing.
With an online auction, your equipment is in front of buyers well beyond the local coffee shop. Bidders can watch, research, and bid from anywhere, and the soft close keeps bidding going while buyers are still active. The auction company handles the photos, the listings, the advertising, the bidder questions, the payment, and the pickup schedule.
How they compare
| Private sale | Auction | |
|---|---|---|
| Who sets the price | You | Competitive bidding on sale day |
| Timeline | Open-ended | A set closing date |
| Who handles calls, showings, and paperwork | You | The auction company |
| Payment | You collect and verify it | Collected by the auction company before pickup |
| Reach | Your contacts and your ads | Online bidders plus the auction company's buyer list and marketing |
| Best for | One or two items with a known buyer | Several items, a full line, or when you want the market to decide |
Questions to ask before you decide
- How soon do I need it sold?
- Do I have the time to answer calls and meet buyers?
- Am I confident in my asking price, or would I rather let buyers compete?
- Am I selling one piece or a full line?
- Can the equipment sell from my place, or does it need to be hauled?
How selling with Schaardt Auction Service works
You can consign equipment to our monthly equipment auction at the Schaardt Auction Yard, 71644 NE-50 near Steinauer, or we can sell larger line-ups right from your farm. Trucking can be arranged. We photograph and catalog everything, market the auction, collect payment from buyers, and schedule loadout. Your settlement is paid within 14 days.
Not sure which way to go? Call Clay at (402) 862-5903 or fill out the form on our Sell With Us page. We will look at what you have and give you an honest recommendation, even if that means selling it yourself.
The Sound that Sells!!




